Although Jersey Mike's prides itself for serving up handmade hoagies, you should still be mindful of what you order at the sandwich shop. Another factor to take into consideration is allergies. } ), this is a really tasty sub. I was pleasantly surprised. We were looking for that perfect combo of high quality meat and cheese, on great bread, and fresh toppings that create an incredible sandwich. Lots of herb-y-ness made it interesting. This can take a minute, so be prepared. The other benefit of this chain is the speed behind the actual creation of the sandwich, making them one of the faster sandwich chains out there. Far higher quality than Subway, but also a few dollars more expensive. And to top it all off, the lettuce was a complete afterthought, with just a few strands tucked in the middle. Who puts green peppers and cucumbers on an Italian sub? Firehouse Subs is known for its toasted subs a la Quiznos (rest in peace), but for the sake of fairness, I ordered the Italian sub cold. I went to all three sandwich chains and ordered the same . Your email address will not be published. While they seemed to skimp a bit on the meats and cheese, it tasted pretty fresh. Results were generated by 134 employees and customers of Jersey Mike's Subs and 111 employees and customers of Jimmy John's Gourmet Sandwiches. It may be full of protein and have the least amount of sodium of the bunch, but we had to dock this sub for being high in calories, fat, and saturated fat. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. This the fifth time Ive had customer service issues, that could have been resolved w reasonable customer service and want to be the best! New rules to ensure post quality. You can have your sub hot, or cold, but either way the par baked bread takes at least one trip through a conveyor belt oven. You get meat in every bite, but not too thick a layer like in the Subway and Jersey Mikes subs which stack all the meat on one half of the bread. Similar to Subway, the bread used at Jersey Mike's is always baked fresh, but the meats and cheeses at this chain are sliced fresh for each sandwich. Subway's bread, while tasty and durable when toasted, has been limited to the same flavors for years (with the exception of a new flavor added here and there) and does have a tendency to get soggy with condiments such as oil and vinegar. Tony Dec 5, 2021 at 6:45 pm. They are all about giving you the sandwich the way THEY want you to have it. When they make your sandwich, they cut the meat in front of you to show you how fresh it really is. Great bread to meat ratio, the whole bun was perfectly covered. Firehouse Subs is expanding its locations and the signature move for this sandwich shop is using the highest-quality meats and cheeses possible. I cant say I was surprised that Primos made a great sub, but its probably the closest you can get to an authentic Italian deli sandwich from chain. Vito: Bread: 7.1 Fillings: 6.6 Toppings: 6.4 Value: 7.0 Overall: 6.7, (from the 5100 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, West New York location). While the sandwiches are good, it's the toppings that really push them . I smelled it, I poked the bread, I pulled off the top and inspected the tomatoes and lettuce for any discoloration. Unless you want food poisoning from JJ . Oddly greasy and almost no flavor in any component. Subway undoubtedly has this chain beat with its fresh bread and ingredients, but Blimpie is okay if you're looking for a decent sandwich that has similar flavors as the previous chain. I ordered the same sandwichan Italian subfrom each chain. (There was a Which Wich in New Brunswick I wanted to try, but like many other eateries during the pandemic, it permanently closed). A nice jolt of fresh, hot flavor really perked this plain jane up. We'll absolutely pass on this hoagiesorry Jersey Mike's. Jersey Mike's subs were the most expensive by far. Turkey, ham, provolone, applewood smoked bacon, and mayo. Primo Italian: Bread: 7.0 (wouldve been higher with seeded bread) Fillings: 7.8 Toppings: 7.6 Value: 7.2 Overall: 7.4, Best Bread: Jimmy Johns Best Fillings: Primo Hoagies Best Toppings: Primo Hoagies Best Value: QuickChek Biggest Surprise: QuickChek Biggest Disappointment: Wawa. Subs are prepared Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, oil, vinegar and spices. His friend made a tomato pie. Unfortunately, with great curing comes a great deal of saltwhich explains the fact this regular sub falls just under 500 milligrams of your recommended daily intake of sodium. Needless to say, it was not great. Jersey Mike's is far better than JJ's in my area. Id never been to Firehouse Subs before, but heard good things. The thing about Subway is that it tastes exactly like Subway. A giant Club Sub with turkey, ham. Everything on this one kind of melded into one flavor, which was pretty good. Pick the best hoagie for your health with our ultimate ranking. How to Order Keto at Jersey Mike's Subs. Certified Angus USDA choice top round sliced fresh and smothered in BBQ sauce. Pickled, and slightly hot, they were exactly what this, or any sub sandwich needs. PissedConsumer 2023 All Jersey Mike's allows for much more customization, and it seems to taste a little fresher than Jimmy John's. The onions were sliced incredibly thin, the lettuce was dark green and crisp, and the tomatoes had no residual refrigerator taste or smell. I go to the location in Dedham Massachusetts, They Are An Amazing Team. I ate the cheapest cheeseburgers from McDonald's, Wendy's, and Burger King. Olivia Tarantino is the Managing Editor of Eat This, Not That!, specializing in nutrition, health, and food product coverage. I would actually go and get this again. I submitted a complaint on Sunday, Feb. 5th We LOVE Jimmy Johns but have never experienced You will be automatically registered on our site. This is unfortunate, given that Jersey Mikes is better, but Jimmy Johns is getting more business due to the convenience factor, creating more Jimmy Johns restaurants and less business to Jersey Mikes. Both Jimmy Johns and Jersey Mike have good customer service for fast food sandwich shops. lad May 7, 2019 at 4:36 pm, R.Kelly Apr 2, 2019 at 3:30 pm. I am a big fan of Firehouse. It might be named after the beaches of the Garden State, but with the amount of bloat-inducing sodium you'll find in this sub, you won't be looking too bikini body ready. While I was incredibly disappointed they ran out of the seeded bread and had to resort to the standard white bread, the sandwich itself was a success. Marie Jan 14, 2018 at 3:09 pm, Jimmy Johns by far is the best Amy: This was nice and fresh, with lots of veggies. There is not a lot of meat on this small sandwich, and it's incredibly dry. This - all day. I would say I prefer Jimmy Johns for the "freaky fast" food. Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing. I am no stranger to QuickChek sandwiches. Per regular sub, prepared Mike's Way: 830 calories, 43 g fat (9 g saturated fat, 1 g trans fat), 2,081 mg sodium, 70 g carbs (4 g fiber, 10 g sugar), 39 g protein. At the Kearny location, I ordered the Italian with ham, capicola, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, oil, vinegar and oregano on the regular white roll. Normally with QuickChek sandwiches, Im used to the lettuce spilling out everywhere, or the bread to be stale, etc. It gave this sub a great punchy quality, and elevated all the ingredients with it's acidity, melding the whole thing into a good sub. The bread, while not as good as the seeded kind, was still solid. But if youre in a jam or looking for a late night option, a sub chain might be your only choice. Nobody's gonna mention Firehouse! This girl does, this thing was oozing vegetables. Ive had some very solid QuickChek sandwiches and then Ive had abominations where the bread was hard as a rock. By the time I finished paying, my sandwich was already ready. Subway Tuna Sandwich vs Jersey Mike's A loyalty point program and I'd get a free sub every couple weeks. But at Jimmy Johns, all I got was one sandwich. How much brain power does it take to say.. Got to Somerset location at 5:53. I just wanted to say that jimmy John's peepee is the best in town. Which is better? At both restaurants, my total was roughly six dollars. I can vouch from experience that it is freshly baked everyday. See this thread for details. What a sad sandwich this was. The Number Four is made with two types of meat you'll likely never see on a Subway menu: prosciuttini and cappacuolo, both versions of cured ham. We went to seven of the biggest sub chains in America to test their turkey: Jimmy John's, Jersey Mike's, Subway, Which Wich, Quiznos, Firehouse Subs and Potbelly. The Best Sandwich Chains, Ranked In Order Of Delicious To 'I'd Rather Have Pizza', A good sandwich has the capability to make anything better, The Best Pancakes At IHOP, Ranked For Scientific Flavor Purposes, While Subway may have the lead as one of the most popular, Pizza Party: Ranking Every Major Pizza Chain From Worst To Best (Sorry Not Sorry), Ranking Wendy's Best Menu Items, Including Their New Jalapeo Popper Chicken Sandwich. The toppings are also neatly tucked inside so nothing falls out. Jersey Mike's. It not only falls just beneath the 1,000-calorie mark, but it's nearly equivalent to an entire day's worth of sodiumor the equivalent to 14 small orders of McDonald's French fries. They slice their meat to order for each and every sandwich, so be prepared for a few minutes wait. Amy: This bread always taste kind of chemically to me. She says, "It has the most sodium, sugar and saturated fat out of all the sandwiches. Ok, we know, we know. Not only are 250 of those calories entirely from mayo, but there's also more sodium in the entire sub than you should eat in an entire day. Not terrible. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. At Jersey Mikes, the deli meat and cheese is extremely fresh. Jimmy John's (from the 110 1st Street, Jersey City location) Full disclosure: I used to work at a Jimmy John's in Illinois, so I've witnessed its rise to success and eventual expansion to my home state. Oil and vinegar was used sparingly and gave the sub an extra kick. The meat here is not great quality, which is a major blow. The bread was pretty good, soft but still retaining a slight chew to it. As much as I miss Quiznos, the only location left in NJ is temporarily closed. 2 seconds turned into 20 minutes of waiting along with other multiple frustrated patrons We will not be back to this location and will be advising our town that as long as these two are working there not to eat there. And although Jersey Mikes is more fresh, and tastes better, it is still a sandwich, and it may not be worth it to go out of you way to get one. Another unique thing this chain does that sets their subs apart is steaming all meats before they go on that signature bread - it adds a tenderness that's unbeatable. It's not the lowest-calorie or lowest-sodium sub, but you get an extra five grams of satiating protein with this sub than the Ham and Provolone. Do people in the south really think we don't drink sweetened iced tea up here? Come on Chris, lets go to Subway!. No other sandwich place has the quality and taste of a Jimmy Johns sandwich. Much like Moses, the Jersey Mike's legend starts by the water and seems improbable. single They are the biggest sub chain in the world, with over 44,000 franchised locations. Jersey Mikes is very good also. Overall, this was a very solid sandwich but still felt lacking for some reason. Instead of talking about our favorite sweet treats this Halloween weekend, Emma and I decided to test out our favorite cold cuts. as well as other partner offers and accept our, Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories. (from the 1600 Tonnelle Avenue, North Bergen location), I havent had Subway in years, and cant believe I ever liked it. It was Thanksgiving and all of the other dens set up their tables so eloquently with candles, table cloths and beautiful centerpieces. It's pretty amazing how deli meat, cheese, vegetables, and a condiment (or several) can be so magical when combined together between two slices of bread, or, in this case, a sub roll. Succulent pastrami is grilled to perfection with melted Swiss cheese and then dressed with sauerkraut and Thousand Island dressing. They claim to be unique in "steaming" their meats and cheeses before loading them onto the fresh baked bread. So next time you get in the mood for a cold cut, I highly recommend you ditch Jersey Mikes and give Jimmy Johns a try. If you're really craving it, you don't need much more than a wheat mini, which still clocks in at 600 calories and just under 40 grams of total fat. I ate so much of it when my boys were in baseball, I'm just done with it. Hotspot of the Week: Jersey Mike's Subs. Read more: I ate chicken wings from 5 major chains, and a little-known newcomer beat out all the classics, Read more: I tried chicken sandwiches from 8 major chains, and Popeyes' was a major standout for several reasons. Would You Like to Convert It Into Review? I used to crush the teeter lunch subs. All the lettuce was in the pocket, and all the meat on outside. its obvious they just want to go home.. My son & I decided to go to this restaurant as the last time he went, food and service was decent. Another pleasant surprise. Which is better? Blimpie's sandwiches, upon the first inspection, could be considered to be a bit flat. Scheduled to Open Soon. Jersey Mike's allows for much more customization, and it seems to taste a little fresher than Jimmy John's. JMs are more harder to find than JJs, by and large. The fresh factor doesn't just stop there, though - Jersey Mike's is also cooking their own roast beef and making their signature sauce with a secret oil blend and vinegar. Jersey Monthly. Roast beef, turkey, swiss, applewood smoked bacon, and mayo. But the regular medium-sized sub goes for $8, which pushes it over the edge a bit. Adding or subtracting which ingredients you want or dont want. Frank's Red Hot Sauce, lettuce, tomato with blue cheese dressing. I used to live a block away from one. Its off of a busy main road and a side street with a small amount of parking spots. I love their food but damn their exhaust fans are horrible. (which stands for biggest, meatiest, tastiest), all of which were inaccurate. 80 Laurel Street. We hit the streets and went to Jimmy Johns, then to Jersey Mikes, and two sandwiches later, picked our favorites. This eight-inch sandwich was $8.75. For example, a Burger King Whopper comes in at a literally whopping 670 calories and 39 grams of fat. Jimmy John's is good for something quick/easy and tasty, but Jersey Mike's has better quality ingredients and you get more of everything in each bite.